Ben bjuder på twist utan skruv
Bernanke bjöd som väntat på sin Operation Twist men de som hoppades på att få se en överraskning blev djupt besvikna. Med tanke på det relativt kraftiga börsfallet efter beskedet var det sannolikt många som tillhörde denna kategori.
I press-releasen talade Fed om att man ser “signifikanta nedåtrisker mot de ekonomiska utsikterna, inklusive spänningar på de globala finansiella marknaderna”. Att man mot bakgrund av detta uttalande inte tog chansen att överraska med en skvätt QE3 kommer sannolikt att tolkas som mycket negativt av de som vill se ytterligare stimulanser.
Som bl a ZeroHedge skriver, så verkar det som om Ben åtminstone för tillfället är beredd att offra aktiemarknaden. Min magkänsla om att vi kommer att behöva få se mer panik innan Ben är beredd att överraska med stimulanser visade sig alltså denna gången vara korrekt.
Här är en summering av FOMC-beskedet (via ZeroHedge):
- FED SEES `SIGNIFICANT DOWNSIDE RISKS’ TO ECONOMIC OUTLOOK
- FED TO BUY TREASURIES WITH 6-YEAR TO 30-YEAR REMAINING MATURITY
- FED LEAVES FEDERAL FUNDS RATE TARGET AT ZERO TO 0.25 PERCENT
- FED SAYS PROGRAM PUTS `DOWNWARD PRESSURE’ ON LONG-TERM RATES
- FED TO SELL TREASURIES WITH 3-YEAR OR LESS REMAINING MATURITY
- PLOSSER, FISHER, KOCHERLAKOTA DISSENT FROM FOMC DECISION
- FED REPEATS `EXCEPTIONALLY LOW’ RATES THROUGH AT LEAST MID-2013
- FED TO BUY $400B OF LONG-TERM DEBT, SELL $400B SHORT-TERM DEBT
- FED EXTENDS AVERAGE MATURITIES OF SECURITIES HOLDINGS
- FED TO REINVEST MATURING HOUSING ASSETS IN HOUSING DEBT
- FED SAYS INFLATION `APPEARS TO HAVE MODERATED’
- FED SEES `CONTINUING WEAKNESS’ IN LABOR MARKET
- FED PURCHASES TO BE DISTRIBUTED ACROSS FIVE SECTORS
- FED SAYS 32% OF DEBT PURCHASES MATURE FROM 6- TO 8-YEARS
- FED SAYS 32% OF DEBT PURCHASES MATURE FROM 8- TO 10-YEARS
- FED SAYS 4% OF DEBT PURCHASES MATURE FROM 10- TO 20-YEARS
Här är en kommentar från ZeroHedge:
…when it comes to Twist a lot of it was priced in, but judging by the 30 year reaction, not all. However, when it comes to stocks, the robots had been expecting not just Twist but a significant LSAP component, potentially up to $1 trillion. Which explains the unwind.
…for those who are confused, what just happened today is that Bernanke just agreed to sacrifice stocks (for the time being) until Congress starts cooperating, due to electoral pressure to get fiscal stimulus in order.
Och här är en kommentar från Peter Tchir:
There are lots of things out there that once they have been done, can never be undone. Ben just disappointed the market for the first time. Whether he knew it or not he failed to beat expectations. He has been so good at managing expectations and using that as a policy tool he lost sight of how far ahead of itself the market had gotten. Everyone expected twist and seriously, what’s a 100 billion in size between friends in this crazy market.
He downgraded the economy but didn’t use that as an excuse to do more. There was no new, ingenious idea. If anything they tried to clarify the commitment to hold rates low til 2013 is dependent on economic conditions remaining weak. Yet there were still 3 dissenters.
Ben has been a fan of making markets dance to his tune based on expectations. By disappointing some people I expect his ability to keep the market up by talking will be reduced as Investors will need to see action rather than being told vaguely that there could be action. That will take time to play out and even I have to admit he gave us something today, just not enough.

Beskedet från FOMC och inte minst presskonferensen med Ben ‘Pinnochio’ Bernanke (eller Printocchio som han också kallas) visade på det vi vetat sedan länge – Federal Reserve har inga som helst planer på att sluta med sina kvantitativa lättnader eftersom de inte har något annat val om de inte vill att det finansiella systemet skall kollapsa.


Senaste kommentarerna